Money

Why Savings Rates Don't Always Follow Bank Rate

When Bank Rate moves, savings rates do not always move with it, or at the same speed. Here is how pass-through works and what the FCA has said about it.

Illustration of three rising green bars on a dark base with a gold arrow trending upward and a gold coin

The interest rate on a savings account is set by the provider, not by the Bank of England. This article explains how changes in Bank Rate reach savers, why the pass-through is uneven, and what the Financial Conduct Authority has said about it.

What does Bank Rate actually do to savings?

According to the Bank of England, Bank Rate is the rate of interest it pays to commercial banks, building societies and other financial institutions that hold money with it, and the rate it charges on loans to them. It is the UK’s core policy rate, and it sets the backdrop for pricing across the financial system.

The Bank’s own explanation is that when Bank Rate rises, banks will usually increase what they charge on loans and the interest they offer on savings. When it falls, the effect runs the other way. The word “usually” matters. Bank Rate is an input into a provider’s decisions, not a rule that dictates the rate on any individual account. Our explainer on how markets read a Bank Rate decision covers the wider market side of that story.

Why do providers not simply copy it?

A savings rate is a price that a bank or building society chooses to pay for deposits. Several things sit behind that choice:

  • How much funding the provider wants. A lender that needs deposits to fund mortgages may pay more to attract them. One that already has plenty may not.
  • How sticky the balances are. Money held in accounts that customers rarely review can be cheaper to keep than money that moves quickly in search of the best rate.
  • Account type. Fixed-term and notice accounts tie money up, so they are priced differently from easy access accounts, where savers can leave at any time.
  • Competition. Smaller providers and new entrants often use rates to win business.

None of this is hidden, but it means two accounts can react very differently to the same Bank Rate decision.

How quickly did rates follow the rises?

The FCA looked closely at this during the period when Bank Rate climbed. According to the FCA, Bank Rate went from 0.1% in December 2021 to 5.0% in July 2023. In its December 2023 update, the regulator reported that the average time firms took to pass on a rise fell from 11 weeks for the first six rises, between January and September 2022, to 5 weeks for the next seven, between October 2022 and August 2023, and to 3 weeks for the rise in August 2023.

The same update gave average easy access rates of 0.89% in January 2023, 1.66% in July 2023 and 1.99% in October 2023. In its September 2024 update, the FCA put the average easy access rate at 2.11% in June 2024.

These are averages, so they hide a wide spread between the best and worst payers. The September 2024 update counted 174 instant access or no-notice products paying over 4%, alongside accounts that paid far less.

What did the FCA say it would do?

In its action plan on cash savings, the FCA set out 14 points: eight actions for itself and six for firms. Among them were commitments to:

  1. require the lowest-paying firms to submit fair value assessments under the Consumer Duty and to act against those that could not show fair value;
  2. review how quickly firms changed savings rates after each Bank Rate change;
  3. publish a six-monthly ranking of easy access savings rates; and
  4. challenge firms on large gaps between rates on products that were open to new customers and those that were not.

The plan also expected firms to prompt customers in low-paying or non-interest-bearing accounts to consider alternatives. The FCA said it would take further action if it did not see significant progress by the end of 2023. Several deadlines in the plan have long passed, so it is best read as a record of what the regulator set out to do rather than a list of current requirements.

Why do older accounts sometimes pay less?

An account closed to new customers, often called a closed-book product, can drift behind the rest of the market because the provider is no longer competing for new money. The FCA’s September 2024 update said the Consumer Duty came into force for closed book products in July 2024. From then, it expects any pricing difference between open and closed products to be justified in the relevant fair value assessments.

The same update reported that average easy access rates on open products had improved by 0.5 percentage points since July 2023, compared with 0.4 percentage points for closed products. That is a small gap in that period, but it shows the direction of the issue: loyalty has not always been rewarded.

How do tiered rates and bonuses change the picture?

Some accounts pay different rates at different balances. The FCA’s update flagged what it calls regressive tiering, where lower balances earn higher rates than larger ones. It said this can help attract savers but carries a greater risk of not meeting Consumer Duty requirements, and that accounts with these features need careful monitoring.

For savers, the practical point is to read what rate applies to the whole balance and not only the headline figure. A worked example with purely illustrative numbers shows why:

Balance Illustrative rate on first £5,000 Illustrative rate above £5,000
£20,000 4.0% 1.0%

Illustrative arithmetic: £5,000 at 4.0% earns £200 over a year, and the remaining £15,000 at 1.0% earns £150, so the total is £350. Divided by the £20,000 balance, that is a blended rate of 1.75%, far below the 4.0% headline.

What does a rate gap cost in pounds?

Percentage points sound small, so it helps to convert them. Using the FCA’s published averages, the move in average easy access rates from 1.66% in July 2023 to 2.11% in June 2024 is 0.45 percentage points. On £10,000, a 0.45 point difference is £45 a year, before tax and ignoring compounding.

A wider gap has a bigger effect. On the same £10,000, the difference between an illustrative 1% account and an illustrative 4% account is £300 a year (£400 minus £100). The FCA estimated in its September 2024 update that improvements since its review had delivered around £4bn a year in extra interest to consumers across the market, which shows how quickly small rate differences add up when applied to the whole market.

Interest is also potentially taxable. Our guide to how tax on savings interest works sets out the allowances, and GOV.UK notes that banks and building societies report interest paid to HMRC each year. For savers using the tax wrapper route, what the cash ISA limit cut means for savers is the relevant background.

Is the rate the only thing to check?

A higher rate is not the only consideration. Access rules, notice periods, withdrawal limits and how long a bonus lasts all matter, and balances should sit within the protection limits explained in how the £120,000 deposit protection limit works. The FCA has also stressed that communications to savers should be clear. Its September 2024 update noted that firms sent more than 100m communications to savers in 2023, but that generic, high-volume messages had limited effect and that targeted messages worked better.

For anyone switching, the FCA’s December 2023 update referred to a target for the largest banks and building societies to complete 90% of cash ISA transfer requests within seven working days, which is relevant if the money sits in an ISA wrapper.

Reading the gap between Bank Rate and your rate

Bank Rate sets the direction but not the destination. The rate on a savings account reflects the provider’s funding needs, the account type, competition and the way the account is run. The FCA’s work shows that pass-through has been uneven and sometimes slow, and that regulators now expect firms to explain themselves where savers appear to get less. For households, the useful habit is to compare the rate actually paid on the whole balance with the wider market from time to time, and to note the effect of any change in pounds rather than percentage points.

This article is general information, not personalised financial advice; rules and rates change.

Sources: Bank of England; Financial Conduct Authority; GOV.UK